Waltzby Industries / Opening
Brain Rot: Technology, Internet, and Social Media - Do Humans Still Have A Chance!?
Technology can help us learn a skill, build a business, preserve years of writing, and keep a family connected across the country. It can also consume an evening, sour a perfectly good day, and encourage us to confuse constant activity with a meaningful life.
This presentation follows those effects through our minds, behavior, relationships, information, money, and privacy, before looking at what these extraordinary tools can make possible when people remain involved in using them.
ROT.Our attention and independenceOur relationships and privacyOur capacity to create
Waltzby Industries / Opening
Contents
Explore seven connected subjects through history, research, and ordinary experiences, with particular attention to what happens when technology begins directing the person who intended to use it.
Arrow keys navigate. Home opens the cover. Contents opens this outline. Writings returns to the website.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
A. The Burden of Unnecessary Knowledge
Imagine waking up on a beautiful Saturday morning. You do not have to work. Your family is healthy, the bills are paid, and there is nothing pressing that demands your attention. Perhaps you will make breakfast, take a drive, or finally work on something you enjoy. There is every reason for this to be a good day.
Then you pick up the phone. Within minutes, you have watched a violent confrontation in another country, read about a tragedy thousands of miles away, encountered political accusations, and seen strangers arguing with a level of hostility you would never tolerate in your living room.
You put the phone down, but you are no longer approaching the day with the same state of mind. Nothing has changed in the household. What changed was the information you allowed into it, and the emotional response that information produced.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
A. The Burden of Unnecessary Knowledge
Being informed and being occupied by information
There is a difference between learning something useful about the world and spending hours emotionally involved in events you cannot influence. A storm approaching your town may require preparation. A local road closure may change your plans. Understanding a major public issue may help you make a considered decision. Those are clear connections between information and the way you live.
A continuous sequence of unrelated tragedies presents a different problem. You can be distressed by every one of them without becoming better equipped to help anyone. You may spend the morning feeling angry, anxious, or helpless, then discover that the only practical result is less patience with the people actually around you.
My concern is the assumption that more exposure must always mean more awareness, and more awareness must always be good. Information has a cost when it repeatedly occupies attention, changes mood, and interferes with ordinary responsibilities. That cost rarely appears next to the headline.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
A. The Burden of Unnecessary Knowledge
The world's problems no longer arrive on a schedule
Distant events are hardly a recent discovery. Newspapers carried accounts of wars and disasters long before television, and television brought disturbing images directly into homes. What changed gradually was the frequency, immediacy, and persistence of access. A newspaper could be folded. A news broadcast ended. A person had opportunities to move on without taking an entire communications system along.
A smartphone removes much of that separation. An event can arrive through a notification, reappear as a video, return in a friend’s post, and continue through arguments beneath the coverage. The repetition can make a single event feel like an environment in which a person has spent the day.
There is also no natural limit to the geographic range. The local household can be perfectly peaceful while the screen supplies enough conflict to occupy every available minute. The device has expanded what we can witness much more effectively than it has expanded what we can personally resolve.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
A. The Burden of Unnecessary Knowledge
A documented experience of news overload
Writer Rolf Dobelli reported in 2013 that abandoning regular news consumption had reduced his anxiety and interruptions after four years. That is his personal account.
A broader view appears in the Reuters Institute’s 2025 Digital News Report. Across its surveyed markets, 40% said they sometimes or often avoided the news, compared with 29% in 2017. One anonymously identified 51-year-old woman in the UK described the accumulation of horrific situations as overwhelming. The respondents were not all describing indifference; some were describing the experience of having more troubling information than they could comfortably process.
These accounts give the Saturday-morning example a real-world connection. A person can care about what happens beyond the front door and still find that repeated exposure leaves them less able to enjoy, attend to, or participate in the life immediately around them.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
A. The Burden of Unnecessary Knowledge
Boston showed that distance does not prevent distress
The 2013 Boston Marathon bombings generated repeated footage and extensive coverage far beyond the people physically present. E. Alison Holman, Dana Rose Garfin, and Roxane Cohen Silver examined that exposure in a study that incorporated information about participants’ mental health before the bombing.
Six or more daily hours of bombing-related media exposure was associated with greater acute stress than direct exposure after statistical adjustments. Because people were not randomly assigned to watch distressing coverage, the finding does not settle cause and effect. It does establish that media exposure was a serious part of the event’s psychological aftermath.
The relevance to everyday use is straightforward. Seeing a disturbing event once and repeatedly returning to its images are different experiences. The additional viewing may supply little new understanding while giving the event substantially more space in the viewer’s day.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
B. The Psychological Influence of Social Media
Consider someone spending an hour moving through angry comments, confrontational videos, accusations, and arguments. Each item invites a response: disbelief, irritation, contempt, agreement, or the desire to correct somebody. Even when the person never types a reply, the experience is emotionally active.
Now that person puts the phone down and joins the family for dinner. Nobody at the table started the online argument. Nevertheless, a harmless remark may receive an impatient answer, a disagreement may escalate more quickly, or the conversation may turn toward the controversy the viewer has just spent an hour rehearsing.
This is how an apparently private habit can enter a shared environment. The screen occupies one person, but that person’s attention and mood are also part of a marriage, a family, a friendship, or a workplace. The device does not need to be present at dinner for the earlier experience to influence it.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
B. The Psychological Influence of Social Media
Emotional influence can happen without a conversation
People have always responded emotionally to other people. A tense meeting can make an entire office uncomfortable. A cheerful friend can change the atmosphere in a room. Social media extends the range and frequency of these encounters, including encounters with people whose lives have no other connection to ours.
A large Facebook experiment published in 2014 altered the amount of positive or negative content shown to users and found small changes in the emotional language of their later posts. The study involved 689,003 users. It measured written expression, rather than directly observing what participants felt at home, but it demonstrated that changing a feed could change subsequent expression.
The experiment also drew an editorial concern about informed consent. That detail adds another dimension: people using a familiar social service were participating in a study of emotional influence without the ordinary understanding associated with volunteering for research.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
B. The Psychological Influence of Social Media
Comparing an entire life with selected moments
The second influence is quieter. Someone scrolls past a friend’s vacation, a former classmate’s new house, a coworker’s promotion, and photographs of another couple looking delighted with each other. The viewer’s own life may be comfortable and satisfying, yet it starts looking unimpressive by comparison.
The comparison is uneven. The viewer knows the arguments, bills, fatigue, and disappointments in their own household. What they see from others is a selection. The vacation photograph may be entirely genuine while revealing nothing about the debt, the disagreement before dinner, or the ordinary months surrounding that one pleasant week.
Put enough of these separate successes together, and a person can begin measuring themselves against an imaginary individual who has everybody else’s best features at once. That is a difficult neighbor to keep up with, especially since the neighbor does not actually exist.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
B. The Psychological Influence of Social Media
Research connects passive viewing with envy
Leon Festinger’s work on social comparison described how people evaluate themselves partly through comparison with others. Social platforms make those comparisons unusually available and often unusually selective. A person no longer has to encounter somebody’s apparent success in the course of ordinary life; they can spend an entire evening browsing it.
In 2015, Philippe Verduyn and colleagues examined passive Facebook use through experimental and field methods. Their findings connected passive use with declines in affective well-being, with envy helping explain the pattern in the field study. The distinction between watching and actively interacting mattered to the research.
That gives the concern more precision than simply calling a platform harmful. Reading a supportive message from a friend is a different activity from comparing oneself with an endless series of attractive lives. The application may be the same, but the psychological experience is not.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
B. The Psychological Influence of Social Media
Repeated exposure can become an expectation
One unpleasant post does not explain a person’s outlook. Repetition is more significant because it can influence what they expect to encounter next. Someone repeatedly shown hostile exchanges may begin expecting hostility. Someone repeatedly watching idealized lifestyles may gradually raise the standard against which ordinary life is judged.
The effect can become self-reinforcing through behavior. Expecting an argument encourages a defensive reply; the reply produces an argument; the argument then appears to confirm that people are unreasonable. Similarly, dissatisfaction can lead to more browsing of the very material that stimulates comparison.
The important loss is sometimes difficult to notice because it develops gradually. The person still has the same home, relationships, and opportunities, but approaches them with expectations formed partly by a continuous, highly selected stream of other people’s behavior.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
C. Are We Losing the Ability to Be Bored?
Picture a doctor’s waiting room in 1990. Someone reads an old magazine, another person looks out the window, and two strangers may exchange a few words. Others simply sit. The appointment has not started, and there is very little they can do to accelerate it.
Now picture the same room in 2026. Most of the people have immediate access to videos, messages, shopping, games, music, and news. Waiting still exists, but the experience of waiting without stimulation has become optional. The same change appears at grocery counters, bus stops, restaurants, and in the brief pauses between activities at home.
The appeal is obvious. A phone can make an inconvenient delay more pleasant. The larger question concerns what happens when every unoccupied moment is treated as a problem that entertainment must solve, before a person has had time to think, observe, or simply tolerate a little quiet.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
C. Are We Losing the Ability to Be Bored?
Boredom is uncomfortable, which makes it easy to sell relief
In a series of studies published in 2014, Timothy Wilson and colleagues asked participants to spend a short period alone with their thoughts. Many found it difficult to enjoy. In one experiment, some chose to administer mild electric shocks rather than remain with nothing external to do. The study did not establish that phones created this discomfort. It showed how strong the preference for an activity can be, even when the available activity is unpleasant.
Digital products arrive in that already vulnerable space with an enormous advantage. They can supply immediate stimulation with almost no physical effort and very little commitment. A person does not need to choose a book, arrange a visit, or begin a project. They can simply keep moving a thumb.
Over time, the easy option can become the normal response to even a few seconds of inactivity. The habit is strengthened every time a pause is filled before any other response develops.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
C. Are We Losing the Ability to Be Bored?
More choice can produce a less satisfying experience
Katy Tam and Michael Inzlicht’s 2024 research examined digital switching, including moving between videos and skipping through them. In several experiments, switching increased boredom and reduced satisfaction and engagement. People expected variety to help, but frequent changes could make the experience less absorbing.
That result describes a familiar evening: a person opens one video, leaves it halfway through, samples another, checks the comments, and moves on again. Forty minutes pass without anything receiving enough attention to become rewarding. The person has consumed many beginnings and experienced very little completion.
The frustration can then produce more switching. There is always another option, so the current lack of satisfaction appears to be a selection problem. Sometimes the problem may be that attention is never allowed to settle long enough for an activity to offer what made it worthwhile.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
C. Are We Losing the Ability to Be Bored?
What quiet moments allowed people to do
An unoccupied moment can give a person time to reconsider a disagreement, remember something important, notice the people nearby, or develop an idea beyond its first sentence. These are ordinary forms of mental activity. They do not require a dramatic revelation or a particularly creative personality.
Benjamin Baird and colleagues studied creative incubation in 2012. An undemanding activity that allowed the mind to wander helped performance on previously encountered creative problems. The finding concerns a particular kind of task, but it illustrates why constant deliberate input is not the only way useful thinking develops.
Someone washing dishes may return to a writing problem with a better approach. Someone walking without headphones may work out how to explain a difficult situation. Filling every pause with outside content leaves fewer opportunities for these unfinished thoughts to receive sustained attention.
Waltzby Industries / 1. Technology's Influence on the Human Mind
C. Are We Losing the Ability to Be Bored?
Manoush Zomorodi discusses her own technology habits and the relationship between downtime and creativity. Her TED2017 talk adds personal experience to the research on constant stimulation. Watch here or use the source link below.
Watch at TED ↗ · Source and backup player
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
A. When Technology Stops Being a Tool
Technology has usually been justified by what it helps people accomplish. A telephone makes a conversation possible across distance. A washing machine reduces labor. A computer can perform calculations, organize records, and help someone produce work that would otherwise take much longer. The value is connected to a purpose outside the device.
The smartphone complicates that relationship because useful tasks and commercially valuable distractions occupy the same object. A person can pick it up to find a document and encounter messages, recommended videos, advertisements, and social updates before the document is even opened.
Two people can therefore use identical technology in very different ways. One researches a subject, completes a task, calls a relative, and puts the phone away. The other checks one message and spends two hours responding to whatever appears next. The second person may have been busy the entire time without doing what they originally intended.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
A. When Technology Stops Being a Tool
A useful task has a finish; a feed often does not
Traditional media often provided recognizable stopping points. A newspaper had a final page. A record ended. A television program finished, even if another program followed it. These limits did not make earlier entertainment harmless, but they gave people repeated opportunities to notice that one activity had ended.
An endless feed can remove that moment of reconsideration. The next item is already waiting. Autoplay reduces the need to choose again. Notifications interrupt other activities with the suggestion that something socially important may have happened.
These features are convenient in particular circumstances, but convenience has consequences when it repeatedly favors continuing. A system can become easier to remain inside than to leave, especially when the user has no clear purpose beyond seeing whether the next item will be more interesting.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
A. When Technology Stops Being a Tool
Habit grows through small, repeated decisions
Someone may begin checking a phone whenever there is an uncomfortable pause. Most checks are unremarkable. Occasionally there is a funny clip, an interesting message, or a gratifying response. That occasional reward keeps the next check plausible, even when the previous several produced nothing of value.
The resulting pattern can be hard to recognize because no individual check seems consequential. A person may honestly say they only looked for a moment. The problem emerges when the moments are repeated throughout work, meals, conversations, and leisure. Each interruption also makes returning to the previous activity more difficult.
This does not require describing every frequent user as addicted. A less dramatic description already captures a serious concern: a person can develop a habitual response that repeatedly competes with their own intentions. They retain the ability to choose while exercising it less deliberately.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
A. When Technology Stops Being a Tool
The cost becomes clearer across a year
An extra half hour is easy to dismiss when it is scattered into brief sessions. Over a year, thirty minutes a day becomes 182.5 hours. Two hours a day becomes 730 hours, equivalent to more than thirty complete twenty-four-hour days. Those calculations do not tell us whether the time was worthwhile. They make the scale visible.
A two-hour conversation with a distant friend and two hours of irritated scrolling belong to very different experiences, even though both may appear as screen time. What matters is what happened during the time and what other activities were displaced.
The interactive display converts a chosen number of daily minutes into a year. It is arithmetic, not a diagnosis or a measurement of your habits. The numbers become meaningful when connected to something a person has repeatedly said they have no time to do.
Daily minutes × 365 ÷ 60. No usage data is collected.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
A. When Technology Stops Being a Tool
What changed when people deactivated Facebook
Hunt Allcott and colleagues studied people who deactivated Facebook for four weeks before the 2018 U.S. midterm elections. Deactivation increased some offline activities, including socializing with friends and family, and improved subjective well-being. Participants also knew less factual news, and some of the reclaimed time went to watching television alone.
That last detail matters because the absence of one application does not automatically create a meaningful alternative. A habit can be replaced with another passive activity. Still, the experiment showed that changing access could change daily behavior and how people evaluated the service afterward.
It also exposed a limitation in treating continued use as proof of continued satisfaction. Someone can repeatedly use a service and discover, after a break, that they value it less than they assumed. The habit itself can keep a person from making that comparison.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
B. Technology's Influence on Human Behavior
A disagreement between friends once often unfolded in person or over a telephone. Those conversations could go badly, but they carried information beyond the words: emphasis, hesitation, a change in volume, the recognition that somebody was joking, and the opportunity to correct a misunderstanding immediately.
Text messages remove much of that information while making rapid responses exceptionally easy. A person reads a short answer in an irritated tone, replies defensively, and receives another short answer. Within minutes, both may be responding to intentions the other never had.
The speed creates a misleading sense that the exchange works like spoken conversation. It can feel immediate and informal while lacking many of the cues that make immediate conversation understandable. We are communicating quickly, but speed is not the same thing as accuracy.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
B. Technology's Influence on Human Behavior
The sender hears a tone the reader cannot hear
Justin Kruger, Nicholas Epley, and colleagues examined this problem in five experiments published in 2005. People overestimated how effectively they could communicate tone through email. The sender knew whether a statement was intended as serious or sarcastic and had difficulty appreciating how little of that intention reached the reader.
The research gives a useful explanation for familiar disputes. Someone writes a remark while mentally hearing a friendly voice. The recipient sees only the sentence, perhaps after a tiring day or in the middle of an existing disagreement. Both can feel certain about what the sentence means.
The original message may have taken five seconds to write; explaining what it was supposed to mean can occupy the rest of the evening. The argument is especially frustrating because neither person believes they introduced the misunderstanding. Each has access to information the other lacks, and the medium makes that difference less obvious than it would be across a table.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
B. Technology's Influence on Human Behavior
A private disagreement can become public evidence
The screenshot changes more than the number of people who know about an argument. It changes what the participants are trying to accomplish. A private exchange can be repaired through an explanation, an apology, or a willingness to move on. Once the exchange has an audience, appearing justified may become more important than repairing the relationship.
The audience also receives a selection. The screenshot may be authentic while leaving out earlier messages, shared history, or the conversation that followed. People who have never met either participant can become confident judges of the entire relationship.
Earlier generations had gossip, letters, and public embarrassment. Digital communication adds exceptional speed, reproducibility, and reach. A few taps can turn a temporary disagreement into a durable record that continues circulating after the original participants would have preferred to forget it.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
B. Technology's Influence on Human Behavior
Instant delivery has become an expectation of instant availability
A message can reach somebody almost immediately, so a delayed reply can begin to look like a decision about the sender. Ten minutes becomes enough time to wonder whether the recipient is uninterested, rude, angry, or deliberately withholding attention.
Read receipts and online indicators strengthen the impression that an explanation is available. A person was online; therefore, the reasoning goes, they could have answered. But the indicator does not explain an interruption, a difficult workday, a need to consider the reply, or the simple choice to finish another activity first.
The technology reports a fragment of behavior. The relationship supplies an interpretation. When the interpretation becomes an expectation of permanent access, the phone has changed the social obligation attached to friendship, family, and employment.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
B. Technology's Influence on Human Behavior
Work and personal life become harder to separate
The same expectation reaches into evenings and weekends. A supervisor sends a quick message because the device makes it easy. The employee sees it during dinner and begins thinking about work, even if no immediate answer was formally required. The interruption can extend beyond the seconds needed to read it.
In a group, these expectations can develop without anyone explicitly establishing them. Some people reply quickly, others notice, and silence begins to seem less committed. Being reachable becomes a performance of responsibility alongside the actual work.
Technology can save time for the sender while consuming attention elsewhere. Across a household, the cumulative effect may be meals interrupted, plans postponed, and people physically together while mentally responding to several different places. The convenience is real, but so is the redistribution of the inconvenience.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
GPS offers a clear example of a task being completed without the same amount of learning taking place. Someone follows instructions to a destination twenty times, yet struggles to find it when the phone is unavailable. They have practiced responding to directions more than understanding the route.
Earlier drivers often studied a map, located a destination relative to familiar streets, watched for landmarks, and remembered mistakes. Those activities required a mental representation of the surrounding area. Turn-by-turn guidance can reduce the need for that representation.
This does not make navigation assistance a bad invention. It reveals a consequence of convenience that applies to many tools: when a system performs a part of a task for us, we may stop exercising the ability that part once required.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
Following instructions and understanding a place
Dahmani and Bohbot examined GPS experience and spatial memory in fifty drivers, with a smaller follow-up group studied over time. Greater GPS use was associated with poorer performance on aspects of self-guided spatial memory. The samples were limited, but the study directly addressed the difference between successful navigation with assistance and knowledge usable without it.
That difference is easy to observe outside a research setting. A driver may recognize the moment the phone says to turn while being unable to describe how two neighborhoods connect. When a road closes or a device fails, the missing broader understanding becomes more consequential.
The tool has made the immediate journey easier. Whether it also helped the person become a more capable navigator depends on what the person was doing mentally during the journey.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
Search changes what people remember
In 2011, Betsy Sparrow, Jenny Liu, and Daniel Wegner studied how expecting future access to information affected memory. Across their experiments, people could show lower recall of the information itself while better remembering where it could be found. The researchers connected this to transactive memory: relying on resources outside the individual to retain knowledge.
There is nothing inherently strange about that arrangement. People have long relied on libraries, notebooks, specialists, and one another. The modern difference is how quickly the external resource can be consulted and how many ordinary decisions now assume it will be available.
A person can become highly skilled at locating answers while retaining less of the background needed to evaluate them. Finding a page is useful. Recognizing whether its claim makes sense still requires some knowledge that is already present in the person doing the searching.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
Calculators and writing tools change which abilities get practiced
A calculator can help a student work on a more complex mathematical problem. If the student never learns to estimate, however, the device can return a wildly implausible answer without prompting concern. The calculation is correct for the numbers entered; the person has lost a way to notice that the inputs were wrong.
Spelling correction and automated writing assistance create similar distinctions. Correcting a word helps the document. Learning why it was wrong helps the writer. A tool can perform the first activity without ensuring the second occurs.
Clark and Chalmers’ philosophical account of the extended mind treats reliable external aids as possible parts of thinking itself. That is a useful perspective, but it leaves an important practical question: what contribution is the person still making, and what happens when the external aid is unavailable or mistaken?
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
Two students can submit equally polished essays and learn very differently
The first student asks AI to produce the entire assignment, reads enough to confirm it resembles an essay, and submits it. The document may be coherent, appropriately formatted, and thoroughly disconnected from any serious work by the student.
The second student uses AI to identify sources, compare explanations, and challenge an argument. They read the material, decide what they believe, write the essay, and use feedback to revise it. The assistance may be extensive, but the student is still exercising judgment throughout the process.
The difference is not visible in a word count or a smooth introduction. It appears in whether the person can explain the reasoning, recognize a weak source, respond to objections, and use what they learned in a new situation. A finished product can conceal how little development took place in producing it.
Waltzby Industries / 2. Technology, Independence & Human Behavior
C. Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?
AI can reduce effort without removing the need for judgment
A 2025 study by researchers at Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon surveyed 319 knowledge workers about critical thinking during AI-assisted work. Higher confidence in AI was associated with lower reported critical-thinking effort, while confidence in one’s own abilities was associated with greater effort. The study measured reported experiences rather than long-term changes in intelligence.
The concern is nevertheless recognizable. Reviewing a fluent answer can feel easier than constructing one, especially when the output already sounds professional. A person may begin accepting wording because it is plausible and well organized, rather than because the underlying claims have been examined.
The work changes from generating to checking, integrating, and deciding. If those activities remain serious, the tool can be valuable. If they become a quick approval of whatever appeared, the appearance of competence can grow while the person’s actual involvement shrinks.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
Imagine following somebody online for ten years. You have seen their wedding photographs, watched their children grow, read their opinions, and followed their vacations. You know when they moved, what they drive, and which political subjects upset them. There is enough accumulated detail to create a strong feeling of familiarity.
But perhaps you have never spoken privately, shared a responsibility, or encountered each other during a difficult situation. You know what they publish. You may know very little about how they listen, handle disappointment, treat someone who cannot help them, or behave when there is no audience.
The familiarity is real as an experience. The mistake is assuming it necessarily amounts to the same knowledge that develops in a reciprocal relationship. Ten years of updates can provide a great deal of information without providing much evidence of how two people would actually relate to each other.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
Public familiarity has a history
In 1956, Donald Horton and R. Richard Wohl described para-social interaction in mass media. Television and radio personalities could address audiences in a style that created a sense of personal involvement, even though the performer had no corresponding relationship with most viewers.
Social platforms make that arrangement more interactive. A creator can answer a comment, use a viewer’s name, or speak casually from a bedroom rather than a studio. These encounters can make the relationship feel less distant, even when the audience is far too large for mutual knowledge.
An occasional response can mean something to the recipient without changing the basic scale. A person who feels deeply understood by a creator may still be one of thousands of names the creator cannot recognize. The intimacy of the presentation and the reciprocity of the relationship remain separate questions.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
What changes when two people actually begin communicating
Compare following a public account with meeting someone online and gradually developing a private relationship. The second relationship can involve questions, explanations, disagreement, humor, and the discovery that the other person remembers something important. Each participant is responding to a particular person rather than addressing an audience.
Over time, consistency becomes evidence. Someone follows through on a promise, remains present during a difficult week, admits a mistake, or respects something shared in confidence. These experiences can establish trust even when the people live far apart.
The internet made the introduction possible. The developing relationship depends on what the people do afterward. A feed can provide familiarity without much reciprocal effort; a meaningful friendship requires the participants to become involved in each other’s actual lives.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
Online dating changed who makes the introduction
Before dating services became widely available online, people commonly met through friends, relatives, neighborhoods, churches, work, and other shared settings. Those introductions carried context. Somebody knew how the person behaved around others, or the potential couple had already encountered each other in ordinary circumstances.
Web-based dating increased access beyond those networks. Profiles made it possible to search for particular characteristics and begin a conversation with someone a person would probably never otherwise meet. Later app interfaces made quick visual selection more prominent in the experience.
Research by Michael Rosenfeld, Reuben Thomas, and Sonia Hausen documented online meeting becoming the leading way heterosexual American couples met. Their analysis identified a major change in introductions. It did not mean that a computer had acquired the ability to know whether two people would be good partners.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
More potential partners means a different kind of uncertainty
A larger pool can help someone whose interests, location, or circumstances make local introductions difficult. It also means more encounters without shared social context. The profile must do work that a mutual friend or familiar setting might once have done.
A description such as kind, independent, or family-oriented can mean different things to different readers. The words are easy to supply and difficult to verify before interaction. A person may also present what they hope to become, or what they are like under ideal circumstances, rather than their most typical behavior.
In everyday introductions, information can accumulate before romantic interest becomes central. Online, interest may develop first, with basic context arriving later. That reversal can make disappointment feel like deception even when the original presentation was an optimistic selection rather than a deliberate fabrication.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
A genuine photograph can create an inaccurate expectation
Suppose somebody chooses a photograph taken several years earlier, on a particularly good day, from an unusually flattering angle. It is a real photograph of the real person. Yet the expectation it creates may differ considerably from the person who arrives for dinner.
The same selection happens in descriptions. A profile emphasizes travel because the person enjoys a yearly vacation. The reader imagines someone constantly looking for the next adventure. Both can believe their interpretation was reasonable. The difference becomes apparent only when they discuss how they actually spend most weekends.
Hancock and Toma examined the accuracy of fifty-four online dating photographs in a 2009 study. Their research addressed the gap between self-presentation and outside assessment, a useful reminder that choosing an authentic image is not the same as providing a representative one.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
A documented mismatch without a simple villain
In their 2006 interviews with online daters, Nicole Ellison, Rebecca Heino, and Jennifer Gibbs explored the tension between making an attractive impression and presenting a self that would remain credible in person. One participant described meeting a woman whose use of average to describe her body did not match his understanding of the term.
The example is useful because it does not depend on inventing a dishonest character. People can interpret the same ordinary descriptor differently. A person can also have an inaccurate view of themselves, either more flattering or more critical than another observer’s.
The researchers described a complicated process of selection, aspiration, interpretation, and anticipated future meetings. That is much closer to real human behavior than assuming every mismatch must involve a carefully planned lie. Profiles are written by people who are trying to be understood and trying to be appealing, often at the same time.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
From a public profile to an actual encounter
Public profiles offer selected information to many people. Private messages make it possible to ask about the details. Telephone calls add timing, emphasis, and the way a person responds without carefully editing every sentence. Video adds expression and some of the setting. An in-person meeting adds shared space, ordinary manners, and spontaneous reactions.
Each change can introduce information that the previous medium left out. A person who writes beautifully may struggle with conversation. Someone initially reserved in messages may be warm and engaging when spoken to. A long conversation can feel intimate while still leaving major practical incompatibilities unexplored.
These transitions do not form a guaranteed ladder toward a successful relationship. They change what the people have an opportunity to learn. The interactive comparison below shows what becomes available, and what can still remain uncertain.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
Real relationships and unpleasant experiences share the same platforms
Pew Research Center’s 2023 reporting, based on a 2022 survey, found that about half of people who had used online dating described their experiences positively. It also found that 48% had encountered at least one of four unwanted behaviors examined by the survey, including unwanted continued contact or offensive messages.
These findings describe an environment in which genuine opportunities and serious difficulties coexist. A successful introduction does not make the unpleasant experiences imaginary, and an unpleasant experience does not prove that meaningful relationships cannot begin online.
The important distinction remains the substance developed after the introduction. A profile, a match, and a pleasant exchange are beginnings. Compatibility and trust require information about a person that cannot be reduced to a photograph, a list of preferences, or the length of time their account has appeared in a feed.
Waltzby Industries / 3. Human Relationships in the Digital World
A. The Illusion of Knowing Someone
MIT researcher Sherry Turkle explores the difference between continuous digital contact and sustained personal conversation in this TED2012 talk. It provides a broader account of why being frequently connected can still leave important parts of a relationship underdeveloped.
Watch at TED ↗ · Source and backup player
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
A social platform appears on the screen as a single service, but the experience is produced by many people making different kinds of decisions. Engineers build ranking and recommendation systems. Product managers decide which results matter. Executives establish priorities and budgets. Policy teams determine what is permitted or restricted.
Legal departments influence how risks are interpreted. Advertisers influence what audiences are commercially desirable. Shareholders can increase pressure for growth. Human resources affects hiring, internal conduct, and the working environment, while research teams may identify effects that other departments must decide how to address.
Users generally see none of those meetings. They see a feed, a warning, an advertisement, a removed post, or an AI response. Understanding the experience requires looking beyond the interface to the organization that decides how the service should operate.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
A business objective becomes a product decision
Imagine a company discovering that confrontational material reliably increases interaction. Executives do not need to write an instruction saying make everyone angry. They may ask for higher engagement, and teams may respond by improving the system’s ability to predict what generates a reaction.
If outrage produces comments, shares, repeat visits, or prolonged viewing, it can perform well against that objective. The system can favor the measurable result even when nobody involved would describe the resulting conversations as healthy or worthwhile.
That is how commercial priorities can become ordinary user experience. An abstract target on a corporate dashboard becomes a particular item at the top of a person’s feed. The decisions are separated by departments and technical processes, but the connection between the target and the encounter still exists.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
Recommendation systems make choices through measurable signals
YouTube’s 2021 explanation of its recommendation system described several signals, including clicks, watch time, survey responses, sharing, likes, and dislikes. It also described efforts to evaluate quality and reduce recommendations of certain problematic material. The company’s own account makes clear that recommendation is a designed combination of objectives and measurements, rather than a simple list of whatever was uploaded most recently.
The choice of signals matters. Watching something does not always mean valuing it. A viewer may remain because they are fascinated, irritated, confused, or waiting to see whether a claim will be justified. The system has to interpret behavior that can have very different meanings.
These interpretations influence what returns. A single unusual viewing session can become information about a person’s interests, even when the person regarded the session as an exception rather than a preference.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
Responsibility can become difficult to locate
Intentional design, commercial pressure, organizational policy, and unintended consequences should not be treated as interchangeable explanations. A rule may be deliberately written, while the way it affects a particular user may be unexpected. An engineer may optimize a prediction without choosing individual posts. An executive may approve a growth target without examining every effect of reaching it.
The organization can therefore produce an outcome that no single participant fully intended. It can also continue producing an outcome after enough people understand the consequences. Those situations involve different degrees of knowledge and responsibility.
For the user, both can feel like being directed by an unseen authority. The distinction helps explain how decisions are made; it does not make the consequences disappear. Complexity should make accountability more careful, not make it impossible.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
Artificial intelligence has several layers of influence
An AI assistant’s response can reflect its training material, technical architecture, post-training, instructions, retrieved sources, product settings, and the current conversation. Different services combine those components in different ways. The sentence a user sees may be the result of several layers acting together.
Ouyang and colleagues’ 2022 research on instruction-following models illustrates one part of that process. Human demonstrations and preferences were used to shape behavior beyond the model’s initial training. The people selecting examples and evaluating responses therefore influenced what kinds of answers were rewarded.
That does not identify the origin of every awkward phrase, refusal, or unwanted qualification. It does show why the result should not be imagined as the independent intention of one person or a machine operating outside all institutional influence.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
A user experiences the policy, even without seeing it
Someone asks an AI to help develop an opinion essay. The system produces polished language but repeatedly softens the argument, adds explanations the writer did not request, or replaces a distinctive voice with a safer-sounding one. From the user’s perspective, the tool is interfering with the work.
There may be several influences behind the result: general training toward agreeable responses, product instructions, uncertainty about the request, or learned patterns of what evaluators tend to prefer. The answer alone may not reveal which explanation is correct.
The broader issue is control over expression. A tool that helps people write also participates in choices about wording, emphasis, and what is treated as acceptable. When those choices are difficult to inspect, users must spend additional effort identifying and reversing changes they never wanted in the first place.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
A. Who's Really Making the Decisions?
Former Google design ethicist Tristan Harris explains how commercial competition and interface design can shape attention. His TED2017 argument connects everyday features with the priorities of the organizations that build them.
Watch at TED ↗ · Source and backup player
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
Two neighbors live on the same street, shop at the same store, pay taxes to the same government, and experience many of the same local conditions. Yet one spends an evening seeing stories about crime, economic difficulty, corruption, and social disorder. The other sees technological breakthroughs, business opportunities, community improvements, and successful people.
Their immediate environments overlap, but the information repeatedly supplied to them differs. Over time, one may approach a conversation assuming society is deteriorating rapidly, while the other wonders why anyone would miss the obvious signs of improvement.
Both can produce examples. Both may feel that their view is simply what the evidence shows. The disagreement is partly about interpretation, but it may also begin earlier, with the selection of evidence each has repeatedly encountered.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
A selected sample can feel like the whole society
A feed supplies examples rather than a representative survey of the world. The viewer sees what was published, what their network distributed, what they chose to follow, and what the platform ranked. Several layers of selection have already occurred before the first item appears.
Repeated exposure can make certain problems seem more common or certain lifestyles more ordinary than they are in the broader population. Dramatic incidents are also easier to remember than uneventful days. A hundred ordinary journeys seldom compete successfully with one frightening video from a road.
The resulting perception is not necessarily invented. The incident may be entirely real. The difficulty is moving from a collection of memorable incidents to a confident claim about how frequently something happens, whether it is becoming more common, and how it compares with other risks.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
Shared media also selected reality, but often selected it publicly
Newspaper editors, radio producers, and television networks have always chosen which events deserved attention. Earlier media were not neutral windows onto everything important. Their decisions could exclude perspectives, exaggerate incidents, and reflect political or commercial interests.
A significant difference was that large audiences often encountered the same edition or broadcast. People could disagree about it while knowing which account they were discussing. Personalized systems make the selection itself more variable. Two people can use the same service at the same time and receive markedly different material.
That change complicates disagreement. A family member may be reacting to a pattern another family member has hardly seen. Each can assume the other is ignoring obvious information when the platforms have been supplying them with different daily examples.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
How the information environment changed
Morse’s Washington–Baltimore telegraph demonstration in 1844 made near-immediate communication across distance a practical reality. Later newspapers and wire services organized distant reports for readers. Radio and television brought shared schedules and simultaneous audiences.
The web greatly expanded who could publish and what could be found. Social networks connected publication to personal endorsement and continuous feedback. Personalized ranking then made the order and selection increasingly individual. Generative AI adds another development: a service can produce a custom account rather than merely recommend an existing one.
Across these changes, the recurring questions concern who selects information, what the audience can inspect, and how people compare what they have received. Transmission became faster and access became wider. Agreement about what the information means did not automatically follow.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
Algorithms are part of the explanation, not the whole history
People select friends, sources, and communities for themselves as well. A person can deliberately follow one viewpoint, avoid a relative’s posts, or seek out a particular kind of conflict. Personalization responds to these choices and can also influence what choices become visible afterward.
An experiment published in 2023 moved consenting Facebook and Instagram users to chronological feeds during the 2020 election period. It substantially changed exposure and reduced activity, but did not significantly change key polarization measures during the three-month study. That result limits the claim that one adjustment to ranking can quickly reverse deeply established attitudes.
The problem is broader than a sorting method. Social groups, prior beliefs, institutions, and habits all participate. Personalized media adds another mechanism through which people can maintain very different perceptions while believing they are simply keeping up with the world.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
What happens when those different perceptions meet at dinner
The disagreement can become personal because people interpret information habits as evidence of intelligence or character. One person sees another’s concern as gullibility; the other sees the dismissal as blindness or indifference. Each begins explaining not only the issue but what must be wrong with the person who sees it differently.
Critical thinking becomes important before the argument reaches that stage. A vivid example, a frequently repeated claim, a measured trend, and a personal interpretation are different kinds of information. A feed often presents them in a similar visual format, with similar counters and similarly confident commentary.
When those distinctions disappear, confidence can increase faster than understanding. The participants have more material to repeat, but less common ground about what would count as a good reason to reconsider it.
Waltzby Industries / 4. Who Controls Our Digital Experience?
B. The Disappearance of Shared Reality
Eli Pariser’s TED2011 talk introduced a widely discussed account of personalized information environments. It belongs here as an influential historical argument, alongside the later research examining what changes in ranking actually do.
Watch at TED ↗ · Source and backup player
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
Someone posts an ordinary family photograph and receives twelve likes. The following week, they publish an outrageous statement and receive fifty thousand views, thousands of comments, and attention from people who had never noticed them before. The difference is visible immediately, and the platform provides the numbers to confirm it.
The second post may be less thoughtful, less accurate, and less representative of the person’s character. It has still performed better in the terms the system makes easiest to see. If attention also brings subscribers, advertising revenue, or sponsorship opportunities, the lesson becomes financial as well as social.
This is the connection between craving attention and making money. Recognition can become a reward in itself, while the ability to convert recognition into income can encourage people to repeat whatever generated the strongest reaction. An ordinary desire to be noticed becomes part of a commercial incentive.
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
The audience does not have to approve to be valuable
Advertising generally depends on reaching an audience. Subscription products depend on persuading part of that audience to pay. Affiliate links, sponsorships, paid promotions, and merchandise create additional ways to turn visibility into revenue. The details differ across platforms and creators, but sustained attention is often essential.
A viewer who disagrees can still contribute to that attention. They may watch to the end, write a correction, share the post with an irritated comment, or return to see the response. Their objection can help distribute the material they dislike.
That creates an uncomfortable situation for public conversation. Being considered objectionable can become commercially useful. A creator may be rewarded for producing an argument nobody enjoys having, provided enough people remain involved in it. The audience is criticizing the performance while helping it reach the next audience.
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
Creators can learn to escalate
Imagine a creator who begins with useful commentary. A measured explanation attracts a modest audience. A more aggressive version attracts a larger one. An accusation attracts more still. Each result offers information about what receives attention, and the pressure to repeat the strongest result can develop gradually.
Brady and colleagues’ 2021 research combined observational work and experiments to examine how social learning can amplify online outrage expression. Positive feedback for expressions of outrage increased the likelihood of later expressions, while perceived network norms also influenced behavior.
That mechanism does not require the creator to begin as a cynical manipulator. A person can learn from the response around them and adjust the public version of themselves accordingly. Eventually the audience may expect a level of anger the person now feels obliged to supply, even on a day when nothing particularly outrageous has happened.
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
Emotionally charged language travels through groups
In their 2017 analysis of social-media messages about polarizing political issues, Brady and colleagues found that moral-emotional language was associated with greater diffusion, particularly within ideological groups. A later replication and meta-analysis supported a positive relationship, while estimating a smaller overall effect than the original study.
The point is not that one extra angry word guarantees success. It is that moral emotion can help information spread through groups already receptive to its framing. A message can invite people to demonstrate loyalty, indignation, or shared values by passing it along.
A carefully qualified explanation has to compete with that appeal. The more dramatic statement may travel farther before anyone considers whether it represents the subject well. Visibility then becomes part of its apparent credibility: so many people are discussing it that others assume it must deserve the attention.
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
Popularity can become part of a person's identity
For some users, likes and followers begin as feedback about a particular post and become a measure of personal worth. A quiet response feels less like an unremarkable publishing result and more like rejection. A sudden surge feels like evidence that the person matters.
Goffman’s account of everyday self-presentation preceded social platforms by decades. People have always adjusted behavior in front of others. The digital difference includes public numerical feedback, a larger potential audience, and a record that allows constant comparison across time and between people.
The performance can begin shaping the experience it was supposed to document. A disagreement becomes content. A private disappointment becomes a possible audience-building story. Even a meal can start requiring a lighting department before anyone is allowed to eat it. The person may still be living their life, but increasingly does so with an imagined response already in mind.
Waltzby Industries / 5. Attention, Popularity & Financial Incentives
A. Craving Attention: Likes, Followers, Clicks, and Money
Genuine importance is often difficult to count
A parent quietly keeping a promise may contribute more to a child’s life than a spectacular post contributes to anyone. A friend who listens for an hour may matter more than a stranger who attracts an enormous audience for a manufactured dispute. These acts do not necessarily produce the visible signals by which platforms organize attention.
The danger is treating those signals as a complete account of significance. Views tell us that something was encountered. They do not establish that it was understood, believed, valued, or worth producing. Comments tell us that people responded. They do not establish the quality of the response or what it did to the participants.
When recognition and money depend on these counters, people have reasons to pursue what can be measured. Much of what makes a person valuable to others remains less visible and harder to monetize. That difference can influence which parts of life receive effort.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Consider someone who is deeply concerned about corporate tracking. They object to businesses collecting personal information and are understandably uncomfortable with the idea of being profiled. Meanwhile, their public account identifies their workplace, children’s school, regular activities, relationship difficulties, and the dates when the family will be away.
Those concerns and disclosures can exist in the same person. The company’s collection may be difficult to see, while the individual’s posting feels like ordinary communication with familiar people. The audience imagined while composing a post may be much smaller and more trustworthy than the audience actually able to encounter it.
The result is a privacy problem with several contributors. Companies collect information people never deliberately publish, and people publish information they might once have considered private. Both processes can expose a life more fully than the individual intended.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Technology has challenged privacy before
In 1890, Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis published The Right to Privacy in the Harvard Law Review. They were responding in part to the intrusions made possible by photography and an increasingly aggressive press. Private life was already becoming easier to turn into public material.
The historical connection is useful because it shows that privacy expectations develop alongside changes in communication. A household can have an established understanding of what belongs inside family life, only to discover that new technology makes outside publication easier and more profitable.
The modern change adds scale, searchability, copying, and participation by the subjects themselves. A photograph no longer requires a newspaper’s interest to reach a large audience. The person in the photograph, or a relative standing nearby, can publish it instantly and leave the future audience largely undetermined.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
A family album and a public record are different things
A photograph in a family album could be embarrassing, but access usually required some connection to the household. Posting the same photograph online can place it in a different setting, where copies can be made and the original explanation can disappear.
The distinction becomes especially important when parents document children’s lives. A child may later object to a picture, a medical detail, a story about discipline, or the public account of a difficult experience. The material may have been shared affectionately, long before the child could understand what publication meant.
The American Academy of Pediatrics identifies several motivations behind this sharing, including preserving memories, connecting with others, social validation, and sometimes financial incentives. The parent’s intention explains why the post was made. It does not determine how the child will eventually experience having that history available to strangers.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Small disclosures can add up to an extensive picture
A birthday post reveals a date. A school photograph reveals a uniform or location. A sports update reveals a routine. A workplace celebration identifies an employer. A vacation announcement reveals that the household is away. Each item can seem ordinary when considered separately.
Across months and years, the details can describe the movements, relationships, and vulnerabilities of a family. The individual posting may never assemble that picture because they remember the posts as separate occasions. Someone else can search, compare, and retain them in a different way.
Privacy therefore involves combinations as well as individual secrets. A person need not publish an address explicitly for repeated location clues to become revealing. The significance of one harmless-looking detail can change when it is combined with several others.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
A teenage mistake can outlast the teenager who made it
Young people experiment with humor, identity, opinion, and social status. Earlier generations also said foolish things, behaved badly, and tried too hard to impress friends. Many of those episodes survived only within a limited group or became harder to recover as the years passed.
A searchable post can continue traveling after the person has changed. A future employer, partner, or acquaintance may encounter it without the context of age, setting, later conduct, or the conversation surrounding it. An authentic fragment can still be a poor representation of an entire person.
Deleting the original may reduce exposure, but it cannot reliably recall screenshots, downloaded copies, or republications. The practical opportunity to become less visible through time has weakened. Growing up and moving on no longer guarantees that the record moves on with you.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Corporate collection extends beyond voluntary disclosure
The FTC’s 2024 report on major social-media and video-streaming services described extensive collection, retention, and monetization of personal information. The findings included information about users and non-users, material obtained through data brokers, and deficiencies in deletion practices.
The digital record is therefore larger than the public profile. Browsing behavior, interactions with advertisements, device information, application activity, and information obtained elsewhere can contribute. A person may carefully control what appears on their own account while knowing little about the other records being assembled.
This is why the contradiction between voluntary oversharing and concern about corporations does not make the corporate concern meaningless. The two processes operate together. People can reveal more than they should and still be subjected to collection they did not reasonably understand.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
BetterHelp: sensitive information became advertising information
In 2023, the FTC finalized an order requiring BetterHelp to pay $7.8 million and restricting its use and sharing of health-related data for advertising. The order resolved allegations that the online counseling service shared information including email addresses, IP addresses, and questionnaire responses with advertising platforms despite privacy assurances.
The significance goes beyond an uncomfortable advertisement. People seeking counseling are disclosing information in a setting where privacy is part of what makes participation possible. If that information becomes useful to an advertising system, the purpose understood by the user and the purpose pursued by the business have diverged.
This is a documented example of why a reassuring interface does not, by itself, explain the information practices behind it. A service can feel personal and supportive while participating in a much larger commercial data system.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Avast: a privacy product also became a source of data
A separate FTC settlement in 2024 required Avast to pay $16.5 million and banned certain sales or licensing of browsing data for advertising. The action resolved allegations that the company and its subsidiaries collected and sold browsing information after presenting products as protecting users from online tracking.
Browsing histories can reveal much more than casual interests. The sequence of pages someone visits can indicate health concerns, financial difficulties, relationships, work, beliefs, and recurring routines. A record does not need to begin with a person’s name to create serious privacy concerns when details can be linked together.
The contradiction is particularly sharp when the product is purchased or installed for protection. The user’s attempt to reduce exposure can itself create a source of information. The difficulty lies in evaluating practices that remain largely invisible during normal use.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
Strava showed what aggregated activity can reveal
In 2018, a public Strava fitness heat map drew attention to patterns of activity around military locations. The U.S. Defense Department examined the implications and urged caution about the use of connected fitness devices.
The individual activity was ordinary exercise. The larger picture emerged when many recorded activities were combined. Routes and concentrations of movement could become informative in places where patterns carried significance beyond sport.
That is an important part of the privacy problem. A user can understand why a device records a run without anticipating what a public aggregate may reveal. The data acquires meaning through combination, comparison, and the interests of someone looking at it for a different reason than the person who generated it.
Waltzby Industries / 6. Privacy & Personal Exposure
A. The Death of Privacy, and Our Willing Participation
The audience and the purpose can both change
Information shared in one setting can be copied into another. A photograph intended for relatives may become material for a stranger’s joke. A personal account intended to find support may become evidence in a workplace dispute. A collection of ordinary activities may become commercially useful to an organization the person has never heard of.
The problem is not limited to whether the original disclosure was secret. It concerns the ability to understand and control how information about a life moves between settings. Those boundaries become harder to maintain when publication, copying, storage, and analysis are inexpensive.
We have made sharing exceptionally easy. Understanding the eventual audience, the duration of the record, and the uses made of it requires considerably more effort. Most people make the first decision in a few seconds and encounter the consequences much later.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
After all of this criticism, the positive possibilities deserve a serious account of their own. The internet gives people access to teachers, archives, collaborators, customers, and loved ones they could not otherwise reach. Digital tools reduce the expense and technical difficulty of creating things that once required a large budget or a specialized team.
Those opportunities are particularly valuable when distance, disability, limited income, or limited local resources have restricted what someone can do. A person can acquire a skill, make work public, participate in a community, or obtain information that would previously have been difficult to reach.
The benefits are not an excuse for the problems already examined. They are the reason the relationship matters. A tool this capable can contribute substantially to a life, provided the human purposes involved remain more important than the system’s demand for continued use.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
A rural beginner can reach a piano teacher
Imagine someone in a rural community who wants to learn piano but has no nearby instructor. Regular travel would make lessons expensive and difficult to arrange. Without another option, the interest may remain something they intend to pursue someday.
Online instruction changes the starting conditions. The learner can watch hand positions, repeat an explanation, slow down a demonstration, and work through material at a convenient time. Written music and recordings become available without a trip to a specialized shop.
The technology cannot produce the improvement by itself. The person must practice, listen, repeat difficult passages, and continue after the first excitement wears off. Its value lies in making that effort possible and giving it useful direction. Eventually there is a recognizable piece of music where an abandoned intention might otherwise have remained.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
A small business can do work that once required a larger budget
A business owner may understand their customers and service very well while knowing little about web design, programming, or preparing professional materials. In the past, each of those needs could require outside help the business could not comfortably afford.
Affordable software and AI assistance can help draft copy, organize information, build a site, explain technical errors, and revise a design. The owner can compare alternatives and develop a result that would otherwise have remained beyond reach.
The human contribution remains central because the tool does not know the business in the same way the owner does. Someone must decide what is accurate, what customers need, what promises can be kept, and whether the result represents the work honestly. Technology expands the workshop; the business still needs somebody who understands what they are building.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
Years of writing can become something people can explore
A person can accumulate decades of notes, essays, questions, and unfinished projects without having the time or technical ability to organize them for an audience. The ideas may be substantial while the files remain difficult to navigate and the publishing process feels discouraging.
Modern tools can help locate material, compare drafts, research a historical claim, develop an outline, edit a passage, and build an interactive presentation. The result can combine a person’s interests with forms of access that would once have required an editor, a researcher, and a web developer.
That is a concrete positive use of the work taking place here. The underlying questions, opinions, examples, and creative direction remain human. The assistance becomes valuable when it helps those interests receive a fuller, clearer expression and reach people who would never have encountered the original folders.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
A historical example: software helped make Apollo possible
The famous 1969 photograph of Margaret Hamilton beside stacks of Apollo program listings shows a much older form of productive human collaboration with computing. Hamilton led the Software Engineering Division at the MIT Instrumentation Laboratory, which developed guidance software for the Apollo program. The stack represented work by the software teams, rather than one person writing an entire mission alone.
The photograph gives a physical sense of the effort behind a result that can look effortless after it succeeds. People had to understand the mission, anticipate problems, write and test software, and coordinate work across specialized roles. The computer made capabilities possible that unaided people could not have provided in the same way.
It is a useful historical counterpart to today’s enthusiasm about AI. Powerful computing has long expanded human capacity. The accomplishment depends on the quality of the human purpose, knowledge, engineering, and judgment brought to the work.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
Accessibility and distance change who can participate
Captions make spoken material available in another form. Screen readers allow written information to be accessed through sound. Video calls help relatives share daily life across distance, while translation tools can assist people who do not speak the same language. None of these benefits is abstract to the person who gains access.
Digital collaboration also allows specialists to examine shared material, communicate across institutions, and contribute to research without requiring everyone to live in the same place. Medical imaging, computational analysis, and shared scientific resources expand the kinds of problems people can investigate together.
The common feature is that the tool supports an activity with significance beyond remaining on the screen. Someone understands, participates, learns, communicates, or produces something that was previously more difficult. That is a very different relationship from repeatedly looking for the next item to fill an empty moment.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
AI assistance works differently across different tasks
Research with management consultants found that AI improved performance on tasks within its capabilities while performance could worsen on a task outside that boundary. Dell’Acqua and colleagues described this uneven pattern as a jagged technological frontier. Tasks that look similar to people may not be equally suitable for the system.
This matters because a useful experience can encourage broader trust. If a tool helped draft a clear explanation, a user may assume its next confident answer deserves the same confidence. The appropriate level of involvement depends on the task, the consequences, and what the person can independently evaluate.
The strongest collaboration therefore involves more than accepting output. A person contributes knowledge, chooses the objective, examines the result, and revises what does not work. The machine can make a great deal more possible without becoming the final authority on what should be produced.
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
Khan Academy founder Sal Khan demonstrates a vision of AI assistance that helps learners work through a problem rather than merely handing them a completed assignment. This TED2023 presentation illustrates how product design can encourage human involvement instead of making it unnecessary.
Watch at TED ↗ · Source and backup player
Waltzby Industries / 7. Technology's Positive Potential
A. Technology as an Extraordinary Human Tool
The difference is visible in the life around the screen
Return to the person waking up on Saturday morning. The phone can still bring an hour of conflict into an otherwise peaceful household. It can also bring a piano lesson, a conversation with a distant relative, or the material needed to finish a project. The same access makes all of those activities possible.
The difference becomes visible afterward. One session leaves a person with something learned, created, understood, or shared with someone who matters. Another leaves them more irritated, less attentive, and further behind on the things they had hoped to do. Evaluating those experiences does not require pretending technology is all good or all bad. It requires noticing what the activity actually contributed to the person’s life.
The extraordinary possibility is that a device capable of consuming so much human attention can also help a person accomplish something deeply worthwhile. There is still a human life around the screen. The most valuable technology helps that life become fuller.
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 1
- Reuters Institute, Digital News Report 2025 ↗
- Holman, Garfin & Silver (2014), media exposure after the Boston Marathon bombings ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Kramer, Guillory & Hancock (2014), Facebook emotional-expression experiment ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- PNAS (2014), expression of concern about informed consent ↗
- Tam & Inzlicht (2024), Fast-forward to boredom ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 2
- Dahmani & Bohbot (2020), GPS use and spatial memory ↗
- Lee and colleagues (2025), AI and critical thinking; survey of 319 workers ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Rosenfeld, Thomas & Hausen (2019), how couples meet ↗
- Ellison, Heino & Gibbs (2006), Managing impressions online ↗
- Hancock & Toma (2009), accuracy of 54 dating photographs ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 3
- Guess and colleagues (2023), feed algorithms in the 2020 election ↗
- Brady and colleagues (2017), emotion and message diffusion ↗
- Brady and colleagues (2025), replication and meta-analysis of moral contagion ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- FTC staff (2024), A look behind the screens ↗
- Department of Defense (2018), fitness trackers and sensitive locations ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 4
- Library of Congress, invention of the telegraph ↗
- Dell’Acqua and colleagues, AI and the jagged technological frontier ↗
- Sparrow, Liu & Wegner (2011), Google effects on memory ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Verduyn and colleagues (2015), passive Facebook use, envy, and well-being ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Kruger and colleagues (2005), communicating tone over email ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 5
- Wilson and colleagues (2014), Just think ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Baird and colleagues (2012), mind wandering and creative incubation ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Brady and colleagues (2021), social learning and online outrage ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Allcott and colleagues (2020), The welfare effects of social media ↗
- Pew Research Center (2023), experiences of U.S. online daters ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 6
Waltzby Industries / Research & references
Research shelf 7
- Festinger (1954), A theory of social comparison processes ↗
- Clark & Chalmers (1998), The extended mind ↗
- Horton & Wohl (1956), Mass communication and para-social interaction ↗Open abstract / author page ↗
- Goffman (1959), The presentation of self in everyday life ↗
- NASA / MIT, Margaret Hamilton and Apollo software ↗
Waltzby Industries / Research & references